YA SciFi novel. Colonizing another planet. References Heinlein's "Tunnel in the Sky"
TalkScience Fiction Fans
Join LibraryThing to post.
1Bargle5
Had this one up for a while over at Goodreads, but no luck.
OK, this one may be a bit difficult. I only remember one specific bit from the book. It references Heinlein's book, "Tunnel in the Sky" Spoiler for Heinlein's book ahead.
Spoiler for "Tunnel in the Sky"
Near the end, a group of youths have a choice between building a permanent town in the area they are currently in, that may be subject to flash floods or another better placed location that they would have to relocate to. The leader convinces them to stay where they are. End spoiler.
In the book I'm looking for, a group of youths end up on a planet that turns out to be the one from Heinlein's book or one very like it. They stumble on the ruins of Heinlein's group's town and it has been washed away by a flash flood. The main character thinks or says they were idiots or fools for building in that spot. The book doesn't specifically mention Heinlein, but anyone who's read that book would recognize it.
I read this back into the 80s or 90s, though it may be a bit older than that. I think it was a male author, but I'm not sure. I think the author was taking a jab at Heinlein. I know I thought remaining where they were was a bad decision when I read Heinlein's book. Unfortunately that's all I remember, Group of space youths end up on Heinlein's planet.
Eliminated already:
Outward Bound
Putting Up Roots
Farnham's Freehold
Crash Landing on Iduna
There's another thread over at Goodreads that may be about the same book. Link below.
https://www.goodreads.com/topic/show/22201897-sci-fi-colonize-planet-constant-fl...
OK, this one may be a bit difficult. I only remember one specific bit from the book. It references Heinlein's book, "Tunnel in the Sky" Spoiler for Heinlein's book ahead.
Spoiler for "Tunnel in the Sky"
Near the end, a group of youths have a choice between building a permanent town in the area they are currently in, that may be subject to flash floods or another better placed location that they would have to relocate to. The leader convinces them to stay where they are. End spoiler.
In the book I'm looking for, a group of youths end up on a planet that turns out to be the one from Heinlein's book or one very like it. They stumble on the ruins of Heinlein's group's town and it has been washed away by a flash flood. The main character thinks or says they were idiots or fools for building in that spot. The book doesn't specifically mention Heinlein, but anyone who's read that book would recognize it.
I read this back into the 80s or 90s, though it may be a bit older than that. I think it was a male author, but I'm not sure. I think the author was taking a jab at Heinlein. I know I thought remaining where they were was a bad decision when I read Heinlein's book. Unfortunately that's all I remember, Group of space youths end up on Heinlein's planet.
Eliminated already:
Outward Bound
Putting Up Roots
Farnham's Freehold
Crash Landing on Iduna
There's another thread over at Goodreads that may be about the same book. Link below.
https://www.goodreads.com/topic/show/22201897-sci-fi-colonize-planet-constant-fl...
2AndreasJ
Can't help you directly, but you may want to post the query also here:
https://www.librarything.com/ngroups/724/Name-that-Book
https://www.librarything.com/ngroups/724/Name-that-Book
3Bargle5
>2 AndreasJ: Already have, Andreas. Thanks for the thought, though.
4Karlstar
Could it be The Cityborn by Edward Willet?
5paradoxosalpha
I tried some cut and paste from the OP into the new AI search, but got no results. :(
6Bargle5
>4 Karlstar: No, not The Cityborn. Thanks for trying.
7karenb
Out of curiosity, what tagmashes have you tried? It's not often I get to ask someone about a fairly specific search like this; I like to see how other people approach tagmashes.
8Bargle5
>7 karenb: I don't remember. I did some back around when I first put this up over at Goodreads. Now I don't even remember how to do Tagmash searches here.
9karenb
>8 Bargle5: That's easy enough: type in a couple of tags (separated by commas), search, click on Tags, and then you are offered a tagmash option.
Join to post